3.4 Open Licenses and Adaptations vs. Collections

Heather M. Ross

Note: For more information on Creative Commons licenses, please see Section 2, Copyright and Open Licenses.

 

In many situations, such as reuse of a photo in a slide presentation, it is obvious that no adaptation has been created. However, the determination can be more difficult when bringing together multiple works into one larger work. This distinction between adaptations and collections is one of the trickiest concepts in copyright law. It also varies by jurisdiction and, even within a given jurisdiction, a judge’s determination between the two can be subjective, since there are few definitive rules on which to rely.

In contrast to an adaptation or remix[2] of others’ work, a collection involves the assembly of separate and independent creative works into a collective whole. A collection is not an adaptation. One community member likened the difference between adaptations and collections to smoothies and TV dinners, respectively.

1. Like a smoothie, an adaptation / remix mixes material from different sources to create a wholly new creation:

Fruit smoothie ingredients, each overlaid with a different CC license - a generic visualization of the "smoothie" metaphor described in the text.

 

Attributions: “CC Smoothie” by Nate Angell. CC BY. Derivative of “Strawberry Smoothie On Glass Jar” by Element5 in the public domain, and various Creative Commons license icons by Creative Commons used under CC BY.

In a “smoothie” or adaptation / remix, you often cannot tell where one open work ends and another one begins. While this flexibility is useful for the new creator, it is still important to provide attribution to the individual parts that went into making the adaptation.

One example of an adaptation would be an open textbook chapter that weaves together multiple open educational resources in such a way that the reader can’t tell which resource was used on which page. That said, the endnotes of the book chapter should still provide attribution to all of the sources that were remixed in the chapter.

2. Like a TV dinner, a collection compiles different works together while keeping them organized as distinct separate objects. An example of a collection would be a book that compiles openly-licensed essays from different sources.

Four section TV dinner with CC license for each section
Attributions: “CC TV Dinner” by Nate Angell. CC BY. Derivative of “tv dinner 1″ by adrigu used under CC BY, and various Creative Commons license icons by Creative Commons used under CC BY.

When you create a collection, you must provide attribution and licensing information about the individual works in your collection. This gives the public the information they need to understand who created what and which license terms apply to specific content. Revisit Section 4.1 on choosing a license to learn how to properly indicate the copyright status of third party works that you incorporate into your new work.

When you combine material into a collection, you may have a separate copyright of your own that you may license. However, your copyright only extends to the new contributions you made to the work. In a collection, that is the selection and arrangement of the various works in the collection, and not the individual works themselves. For example, you can select and arrange pre-existing poems published by others into an anthology, write an introduction, and design a cover for the collection, but your copyright and the only copyright you can license extends to your arrangement of the poems (not the poems themselves), and your original introduction and cover. The poems are not yours to license.

What happens when you create an adaptation of a CC licensed work or works?

General rules:

  • If the underlying work is licensed under a NoDerivatives license, you can make and use changes privately but you cannot share your adaptation with others, as discussed above.
  • If the underlying work is licensed under a ShareAlike license, then ShareAlike applies to your adaptation and you must license it under the same or a compatible license. More on this below.
  • You need to consider license compatibility. License compatibility is the term used to address the issue of which types of licensed works can be adapted into a new work.
  • It can be difficult to determine the difference between adaptations and collections. The most important thing to remember is that in all cases, you have to attribute the original work(s).

Adapted from Creative Commons Certificate for Educators, Academic Librarians, and Open Culture under a CC-BY license.

Media Attributions

  • smoothie
  • CC-TVDinner-NoAttribution

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License

Introduction to Open Educational Practices Copyright © 2026 by Roberta Campbell-Chudoba; DeDe Dawson; Jade Hupé; Kate Langrell; Kevin Read; and Heather M. Ross is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.