5.4 The Varieties of OA
DeDe Dawson
There are two main ways to make academic literature OA: publishing in an OA journal/book or archiving a published work in an open online repository.
OA Publishing
There are several varieties of OA journal publishing. A gold OA journal makes all articles OA at the time of publication, often through an article processing charge (APC) to authors. A diamond OA journal is a special kind of gold journal that makes articles OA at the time of publication but does not charge APCs to authors. Diamond journals are typically scholar-led, mission-driven or non-profit and are often considered the most equitable model since neither readers nor authors face financial barriers. Diamond journals are supported through a diverse range of funding sources. And finally, hybrid journals are closed-access subscription journals that offer authors the option of making their individual articles OA in an otherwise paywalled journal. Hybrid journals charge high APCs to authors while also continuing to charge subscriptions to libraries.
Commercial for-profit publishers, and large revenue-driven non-profit society publishers, have increasingly adopted APC-based gold and hybrid models. This has resulted in the widespread misconception that OA is expensive and the only route to OA is through paying a high APC.
OA Archiving
Authors can also make their works OA through self-archiving them in open online repositories; this is known as green OA. It is a free and legal way to make works OA.
The libraries at many universities operate institutional repositories for the purpose of securely preserving the works of campus authors for the long term, while also making them accessible and discoverable. Additionally, there are many subject repositories (e.g. arXiv) and large multi-disciplinary repositories (e.g., Zenodo) that exist to serve specific disciplinary communities or researchers whose institutions do not have their own repositories. Preprint repositories have become increasingly important as a way of sharing early versions of works so that science progresses more rapidly, particularly in times of crisis such as during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Authors who choose to publish in a conventional subscription journal can usually make a version of their manuscript OA in a repository for free. This is a way to avoid the high APC prices of many gold and hybrid journals. Authors will need to adhere to the copyright and licensing agreements that they signed with the publisher. Typically, authors can self-archive the accepted manuscript version of the article (after peer review and revisions, but before the final layout, typesetting, and journal branding). Publishers may also require that the article is only shared after an embargo period (often 12 months after publication). Authors are advised to carefully assess publishers’ policies before submission if they want to take advantage of this option. It is also possible for authors to negotiate their copyright agreements with publishers to retain the right to do this.
Other Types of OA
Sometimes publishers decide to make certain articles or issues freely available. This has become known as bronze OA. It is not considered a true form of OA though because there is no open license attached to the works, and there is no guarantee that they will remain free to access. Works that are shared illegally online at pirate sites are sometimes called black OA. Similarly, these are not considered true OA because they lack an open license and their continued availability is uncertain.
Further Reading:
Piwowar H, Priem J, Larivière V, Alperin JP, Matthias L, Norlander B, Farley A, West J, Haustein S. 2018. The state of OA: a large-scale analysis of the prevalence and impact of Open Access articles. PeerJ 6:e4375 https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.4375